Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images
National League East
1. New York Mets
Johan Santana pitching in huge Shea Stadium without a DH in the opposing lineup sounds like a recipe for 20-25 wins. Depth and quality in middle relief will allow Pedro Martinez to become a dominant 6 inning #2 starter (if manager Willie Randolph is smart), and John Maine is ready to emerge as a solid #3. Offensively, the top 4 is pretty damn good–Reyes/Castillo/Wright/Beltran–but after that its seniors in decline (Delgado, Alou) and mediocrity (Ryan Church?! What’s the skeleton that got Lastings Milledge traded?). Brian Schneider is an upgrade over ‘roided Paul Loduca, but the Mets will win a weak division on the strength of their pitching and troika of stars (the top four minus Castillo).
2. Atlanta Braves
If they can stay healthy, they’ll be tough. Kelly Johnson and Yunel Escobar are good table-setters and a decent keystone combo; then come a quartet of mashers in Chipper, Teixeria (in a contract year, no less), a bulked up Francoeur who actually started taking a pitch or two last year, and the young moose McCann. But can Chipper stay healthy enough for his usual 125-130 games, let alone, 162, at age 36? More to the point, how many quality starts does the impressive but aged starting rotation of Hudson, Smoltz, Glavine and Mike f’ing Hampton have left? The bullpen is a little shaky and Mark Kotsay is no Andruw in center. I’m guessing Chipper pulls his normal duty (and produces accordingly), Teixeria and Francoeur are monsters, and everyone but Hampton hangs tough in the rotation, with Jaar Jurrjens (acquired in the Renteria deal with Detroit) a plus at #5. They’ll be in the wild card hunt before losing out to someone in the NL West.
3. Philadelphia Phillies
My oh my can they hit the ball, helped out by that bandbox home ballpark. No first baseman will knock in more runs than Ryan Howard; ditto Chase Utley at second, who enjoys the largest offensive advantage over his peers than players at any other position. MVP Jimmy Rollins is set for another 125 runs scored provided his hammies don’t snap, and Geoff Jenkins and Pedro Feliz are offensive upgrades at the bottom of the order in platoon with Jason Werth and Glen Dobbs. But what kind of pitching is there behind young ace Cole Hamels? Why would this be the year Brett Myers puts it all together? There’s a much better chance this is the year Jamie Moyers finally isn’t crafty enough to get people out varying speeds between 75-85 mph and spotting the corners. Kyle Kendrick? Adam Eaton? Does that sound like a playoff staff to you? And who is the genius who thinks Brad Lidge closing at Citizens Bank is a good idea?
4. Florida Marlins
The Marlins rebuild their roster for the same reason people pick scabs, because it hurts so good. The latest rip-it-raw swap brought them Cameron Maybin and Andrew Miller for their best hitter (Miguel Cabrera) and pitcher (Dontrelle Willis) and will pay dividends (and save money) in about two years. By then, five-tool shortstop Hanley Ramirez and emerging star Jeremy Hermida will probably be on the trading block. Like Washington, Florida has no pitching to speak of besides closer Kevin Gregg, unless Miller develops in a hurry. Unlike Washington, there are a quartet of proven bats (Uggla, Willingham besides Hanley and Hermida), a breakout candidate in Mike Jacobs, and an intriguing comeback in the making with Jorge Cantu. Seventy-five wins would be an accomplishment.
5. Washington Nationals
Yes, there are some head cases that GM Jim Bowden has added to the ballclub, chief among them the wonderfully named duo of Lastings Milledge and Elijah Dukes. Together with hot corner stud Ryan Zimmerman, they will determine whether the Nats are a team on the rise or whether a new stadium is the only excitement. The pitching staff is horrible, and without the spacious confines of RFK Stadium to protect them this season.
National League Central
1. Chicago Cubs
The Cubs will win a weak divison because of the depth of their starting rotation. Carloz Zambrano throws too many pitches but is a rubber-armed horse who can handle the work. Rich Hill and Ted Lilly are a pair of nasty lefties, and Jason Marquis and Ryan Dempster are higher-class retreads than one usually finds in the hindquarters of #s 4 + 5. Bobby Howry, Kerry Wood and Carlos Marmol all possess quality stuff but does Wood have the stamina, Howry enough left, or Marmol the maturity to be the closer, or will it a baton-passing committee. Offensively, you’ve got to figure Soriano and Lee will have better years, Ramirez is uber reliable, and the 30-year old Japanese outfielder Kosuke Fukudome will have Cubs fans gleefully spitting in each others’ faces pronouncing his name. Center fielder Felix Pie and catcher Geovany Soto look like a bright future up the middle, but the double play duo of Ryan Theriot and Mark DeRosa could use a makeover.
2. Milwaukee Brewers
Last year’s Brewers became one of my favorite teams. Portly Prince Fielder swatting home runs to left, right, and center yet finding his .618 slugging percentage only second best on the team thanks to the .634 posted by the Hebrew Hammer and reigning Rookie of the Year, Ryan Braun. The impossibly lanky Corey Hart knocking 24 dingers and swiping 23 bases as a six-and-a-half-foot leadoff man. JJ Hardy hitting a ton early and a few feathers’ worth down the stretch. Turnbow and Cordero tossing gas in the late innings. And yet the Brewers faded down the stretch and finished a titch above .500 at 83-79. The reason was defense: Fielder and Braun were as bad with the glove as they were accomplished with the bat. Despite the acquisition of Mike Cameron to vacuum up flies in center, swapping Braun and Bill Hall at outfield and third base isn’t going to get it done, and ancient Jason Kendall is about as bad as roly-poly Johnny Estrada behind the plate. Cordero is gone as the closer, replaced by the flammable Eric Gagne, and the rotation relies too much on young ace-to-be Yovani Gallardo and injury-prone Ben Sheets. Nevertheless, Fielder and Braun will continue to pound the ball, Rickie Weeks is due for his injury-free breakout at second, and Hart will prove last year was no fluke. Once again they’ll be loads of fun to watch and finish second behind the Cubs.
3. Cincinnati Reds
Another potent offense, especially if new manager Dusty Baker can change his spots and give heralded rooks like 1B Joey Votto and OF Jay Bruce 500 at-bats apiece. Alas, Bruce starts the season in the minors and Votto may platoon with Scott Hatteberg, a walking anti-Moneyball argument. Brandon Phillips and Jeff Keppinger both have some sock and decent gloves in the middle infield (although the Reds’ bandbox ballpark overrates Phillips’ vaunted offense), and Adam Dunn is a walk-homer-or-strikeout suspense machine who churns up divots trying to play left field. Will Ken Griffey Jr. maintain his improbable semi-healthy ways? Can Bronson Arroyo rebound will Aaron Harang maintains to provide the Reds with a bona fide 1-2 punch in the rotation? Can the ex-Brewer Cordero, a notorious flyball pitcher, retain his sanity (and that of his manager) closing in the Great American Ballpark? And can Votto and Bruce get a chance to compete for Rookie of the Year? If more than half of these questions are answered yes, the Reds will leapfrog the Brewers for second and perhaps even bag a pennant if the Cubs falter.
4. Pittsburgh Pirates
If they aren’t the most futile franchise in professional sports over the past two decades, than other franchises are certa
inly losing quietly. But there’s hope here (not that we haven’t thought that before) in the trio of still-young arms in the starting rotation, led by lefty ace-in-the-making Tom Gorzelanny and buttressed by fireballing righty Ian Snell, with lefty Paul Maholm a decent #3 who won 10 games for a team that only trimphed 69 times last season. This is a make-or-break year for once promising lefty Zach Duke and Matt Morris probably doesn’t have anything but guile left. But the bullpen is in good hands with Matt Capps and Damaso Marte–don’t look now, but the Bucs have the second best pitching staff in the division. The lineup isn’t fearsome by any means, especially if Jason Bay doesn’t rebound from last year’s pratfall and 1B Adam Laroche gets off to another miserable start. I think both will rebound, Freddie Sanchez will continue to rake and Ronnie Paulino will develop into a quality catcher. But the rest of the lineup is forgettable. Every journey begins with a single step. Pittsburgh’s is fourth place.
5. Houston Astros
Their 4-7 hitters (Berkman/Carlos Lee/Tejada/Wiggington) sport classic beer-league physiques (I’m assuming an unjuiced Tejada flabs out a bit) and I’m anticipating that one or more of them will go with a major injury this season as a result. Roy Oswalt is a gritty sonavabitch on the mound and Jose Valverde gives them a closer unscarred by postseason failure, but overall the pieces don’t add up here. Hunter Pence and catcher J.R. Towles are potentially exciting young players but the Astros are neither contending nor rebuilding. They’re stuck.
6. St. Louis Cardinals
If Albert Pujols defies the odds and plays like Albert Pujols for an entire season, last place will be a foolish prediction for the Cards. But the deafening whispers are that Pujols still isn’t right from last year’s assortment of injuries, and if a dreadfully slow starting lineup with an injury-besotted pitching staff starts out 12-26 or something, Pujols may go under the knife in May. Then last place is inevitable.
National League West
1. Arizona Diamondbacks
Their lineup is studded with young talent, their pitching staff is loaded even if Randy Johnson can’t come back, and together that should be enough to squeak by in the NL’s toughest divsion. Leading off is Chris Young, who hit 32 homers and stole 27 bases as 23-year old rookie. At short is 25-year old Stephen Drew, who knocked in 60 runs despite hitting an anemic .238. At the bottom of the order is Justin Upton, age 20, an offensive stick of dynamite who many scouts openly tout as a future superstar. It’s unreasonable to expect another monster year from vet Eric Byrnes, but corner infielders Conor Jackson and Mark Reynolds should compensate by upping their power numbers this season. And then there’s the pitching staff, led by arguably the game’s best 1-2 rotation combo, sinkerballer Brandon Webb and last year’s AL All Star game starter Dan Haren (acquired in a deal with Oakland). Micah Owings allowed a very respectable 1.28 WHIP last year (especially for a #3 starter) and lefty Doug Davis is an asset slotted at #4. Can the Big Unit loom large once again? If so, the Snakes could win 100 games.
2. Colorado Rockies
The Diamondbacks are best and the Giants are worst, but the middle three teams could finish in any order, and the best of the trio will earn the wild card. I’ll go with the Rockies because they’re not as young as people might imagine (and hence have more players in their prime) and because the fun generated by last year’s tsunami surge to the World Series has probably been a great off-season motivator. Matt Holliday might be ready to take over for Vlad Guerrero as the best hitting outfielder in baseball, and Garrett Atkins and Brad Hawpe are Vanilla personalities with Cherries Garcia rbi totals. Shortstop Troy Tulowitzki deserved to be ROY instead of Ryan Braun by dint of grabbing the mantle of team leader and not letting a slow start at the plate deter fabulous defensive play throughout the season. Oh, and he came on enough to knock in 99 runs. This is a Rockies team that can hit on the road as well as at Coors (which isn’t quite the high-scoring palace it used to be before they put they deadened the balls in the humidor). Nevertheless, I put them behind the Diamondbacks, and in dogfight with the Dodgers and Pads, because they have the division’s fourth best pitching. Count me as dubious that closer Manny Corpas will post 2.08 ERA and 1.06 WHIP again, or that manager Clint Hurdle can make another stretch run with everyone in the pen pitching lights out and two kids, Franklin Morales and Ubaldo Jimenez, duplicating last year’s numbers. Put simply, the Rockies caught lightning in a bottle from August through October last year, and the hitting was more legit than the pitching. But Steve Francis had arguably the best season of any hurler in Rockies’ history, and that was real. Righty Aaron Cook should stay healthy, and even if Corpas takes a step back, he’ll be pretty good. Whoever wins the NL East or Central won’t want to face this team in the playoffs.
3. San Diego Padres
The conventional wisdom is that the Padres are all-pitch, no-hit, but there is more spark in that lineup than the conventional thinkers realize. Playing half their games in the toughest park for hitters in all of baseball, shortstop Kahlil Greene swatted 27 homers and third baseman Kevin Kouzmanoff overcame a horrible start to launch another 18. First baseman Adrian Gonzalez had 30. Greene is 28 this year, the other two 26; all figure to take another step before hitting their prime. And Josh Bard likewise is a promising hitter due for an upgrade in his rbi’s. The problem is age in a spacious outfield, specifically erstwhile stars Jim Edmonds in center and Brian Giles in right, both now well past their apex. They will test the patience of current Cy Young Award winner Jake Peavy, the tall and talented Chris Young, and the gifted but frequently injured third starter, Randy Wolf. Greg Maddux is your everyday 347-game winner as #4 starter, and Justin Germano rounds out a deep rotation pitching in very friendly confines at Petco. In the bullpen, the abiding question is whether Trevor Hoffman’s late season meltdown finally marks the beginning of the end of his Hall of Fame career. If so, superb setup men Cla Meredith and Heath Bell have to prove one of them can take it to the next level.
4. Los Angeles Dodgers
I was tempted to put the Dodgers second out of affection for new skipper Joe Torre, freed from the once and future Bronx Zoo at Yankee Stadium. But despite a bevy of promising youngsters–especially 1b James Loney, Of Matt Kemp and 3B Andy Laroche–and the league’s best catcher in 25-year old Russell Martin, LA is still a year or two away from truly blossoming. I mean, this is a team whose home run leader was Jeff Kent, who hit 20–half his age. Juan Pierre and Rafael Furcal are go-go speedsters at the top of the order, but giving fat contracts to a couple of poor man’s Maury Wills isn’t the way to win in 2008. Free agent signee Andrux Jones will help at both the plate and in the field–expect a big bounceback from his .222/26/94 disappointment. And the Big Blue has the kind of deep and talented bullpen that Torre craved and never had his final years in New York, what with closer Takashi Saito and lefty-righty setup men Joe Beimel and Big Jonathan Broxton. Like the lineup, the rotation has depth and talent but no drop-dead superstar. The Dodgers shape up to be the best 4th place team in baseball.
5. San Francisco Giants
Speaking of all-pitch, no-hit, the post-Bonds Giants have the worst batting order in all of baseball, the decrepit keystone combo of Ray Durham and Omar Vizquel, has-beens like Rich Aurilia and Randy Winn, and either Aaron Rowand or Bengie Molina batting cleanup. But the pitching is rock solid, with budding star Tim Lincecum and tough-luck kid Matt Cain (7-16 despite a 3.65 ERA and 1.26 WHIP) threatening to supplant big bucks Barry Zito as the ace. Make no mistake, howev
er: This is a baseball team going nowhere fast, stuck in purgatory as their karmic payback for enabling Bonds.